Pink Carnations

Betty D. Plummer

January 31, 1939 ~ November 17, 2022 (age 83)


Betty Dew (Shafer) Plummer, age 83, of Carroll, went to be with the Lord on Thursday, November 17, 2022. Born January 31, 1939, in Nelsonville to the late Charles and Audrey (Bean) Shafer. She was a retired manager with Discover Card, and a member of Lithopolis United Methodist Church, Olivedale Senior Citizens, and the Joy Circle at the church. She was a loving wife, and caring mother and grandmother.

She was preceded in death by her husband, Keith Plummer in 2003.

Betty is survived by her daughters, Deborah (Dennis) Werner, Coshocton, and Wendy (Wesley) Underwood, Carroll; grandchildren, Daniel (Katie) Werner, Derek Werner, Wyatt (Kyli) Underwood, Wylee Underwood; great-grandchildren, Cyrus, Sydney, and baby Underwood and baby Plummer; step-children, David (Linda) Plummer, and his children, Julie Plummer and Brian (Emily) Plummer, Marcia (Dan) Lephart, and her sons, Matthew and Nathan (Hilary) Lephart, Molly (Kenn) Corwin, and her daughter, Angela (John) DiMariangeli, Melissa (Brody) Endsley, and her daughter, Savanna Endsley; several step-great-grandchildren; sister, Lu Evelyn Flowers; brother, Charles (Ann) Shafer; special friends, Rosa Smith and Janet Pritchard; and many nieces and nephews, and other extended family and friends.

Friends may visit 5-7 pm Tuesday, November 22 at the DWAYNE R. SPENCE FUNERAL HOME, 650 W. Waterloo St., Canal Winchester, where the funeral service will be held at 11 am Wednesday, November 23 with Pastor Alex Feldman officiating. Interment will follow at Lithopolis Cemetery.

Special thanks to her caregiver, Helen, for her care of Betty.

Friends who wish may contribute to Capital City Hospice, 2800 Corporate Exchange Dr., Suite 170, Columbus OH 43231, or Lithopolis United Methodist Church, PO Box 42, Lithopolis, OH 43136 in Betty’s memory.


November 22, 2022

5:00 PM to 7:00 PM
Dwayne R. Spence Funeral Home
650 West Waterloo St.
Canal Winchester, OH 43110

November 23, 2022

11:00 AM to TBD
Dwayne R. Spence Funeral Home
650 West Waterloo St.
Canal Winchester, OH 43110


Lithopolis Cemetery
4365 Cedar Hill Road
Lithopolis, OH 43136

© 2022 Dwayne R Spence Funeral Home. All Rights Reserved. | Terms of Service | Privacy Policy